Back on the ice

As the Nottingham Panthers began their new season, a year after they were shaken by unthinkable tragedy, Stacey Smith found out how the ice hockey team has rebuilt and refocused itself for the fight ahead

On Saturday 9th November 2024, the Motorpoint Arena in the Lace Market district of Nottingham was packed to capacity. The fans chanted their support as they piled into their seats before the game and the lovable mascot Paws, an outsized plush panther, revved them up for the game ahead.

The Nottingham Panthers is one of the oldest and most successful teams in British ice hockey history. Founded in 1946, it has a rich legacy, a dedicated fan base and has enjoyed significant success, claiming multiple league titles and playoff championships and currently competing in the Elite Ice Hockey League (EIHL), the highest level of the sport in the UK. The club’s vibrant atmosphere during its home games, combined with its commitment to community engagement, has made the Panthers a key player in British ice hockey and a source of pride for Nottingham’s sports culture.

As the Panthers raced out, the crowd roared their delight, Their opponents, the Sheffield Steelers, joined them on the ice and the game began. The Panthers came out strong in the first period, holding the better opening exchanges. Their opponents couldn’t get near the puck for a time and excitement coursed around the rink. However, the visitors took the lead 17 minutes into the game, setting the stage for an intense battle.

But in this game the stakes were higher than normal. When these two teams met in the last season, just over a year ago, the game ended in a tragedy that was reported around the globe. The Panthers were playing not just for themselves but for the memory of a fallen teammate.

***

The lives of the Nottingham Panthers changed forever on 28th October 2023 when their teammate Adam Johnson was struck in the neck by a Steelers player’s skate during a collision. Johnson, who had only joined the club in August, began to bleed out, and was surrounded by players who gathered around him in a protective ring, locking arms as he was treated by paramedics. He died in hospital shortly afterwards, aged just 29.

The news sent shockwaves across the sporting world, with thousands in the wider ice hockey community paying tribute to Johnson, 47-second silences being held at games (Johnson’s jersey number was 47) and people in Nottingham organising memorials for the fallen player. In response to his death, the EIHL announced the temporary suspension of all fixtures and the Panthers confirmed they would pull out of the Challenge Cup, the competition that runs alongside the EIHL.

The team took a month out of playing to regroup and process the tragedy, playing only one game, a memorial match for Johnson against Manchester Storm. Special jerseys worn by the Panthers at the game were sold to raise money for a fund set up to help Johnson’s family and charities in his home town. The Panthers ended the 2023-24 season in ninth place, missing out on the playoffs for the first time in EIHL history.

Panthers player Jordan Kelsall was there on the day his teammate died. Legal proceedings relating to the incident are ongoing, so he couldn’t talk about the specifics of the day itself. “No one is talking about the situation so I’m not going to speak about it directly,” he said. But he did talk to me about how he and his teammates dealt with the aftermath.

“Everyone who was involved in the situation had an awful experience of course, but I think you have to focus on trying to get back to where we were. Ultimately you need to be strong minded [but] that sounds easier than it is… I think the way we got through it was having a focus that we are going to do this, we are going to get back on the ice.”

Rebuilding took time and was not a smooth process. “Everyone was on different timescales,” said Kelsall. “So some days people would be good and some days people would be bad and there was no rush, everyone was completing their own timescale and it just ended up getting to the point where everyone was just kind of in the same situation and then we started playing again. So that’s how you get through it.”

Kelsall highlighted the work of the Panthers’ management, which organised counselling for the entire team in the aftermath of Johnson’s death. “The organisation did an amazing job keeping everyone focused,” he said. “Of course it was difficult but you get your head down, you’re working hard and, yeah, we had a bit of a break from the ice but we were trying to stay in shape to get ready for when we came back. If people wanted to leave, they had the opportunity to, but 99 percent of the team stayed and we got back on the ice and started playing again.” In September 2024, as a mark of respect and a part of the healing process, a ceremony was held to retire Johnson’s number 47 jersey, with former teammates and coaches giving emotional speeches.

Johnson’s death has changed the sport of ice hockey. In reaction to the fatal incident, in December 2023 the International Ice Hockey Federation announced a mandatory rule requiring all hockey players at every level to wear a neck guard, a move echoed by the UK’s Elite Ice Hockey League. Previously, the EIHL had strongly encouraged players to wear neck guards during games but they had only been mandatory for under-18s. The new rule was scheduled to begin at the start of the 2024 season but could not take immediate effect due to the limited supply of neck guards at the time.

“It’s now in the rulebook,” Luke Fisher, media and communications manager for the EIHL told me. “You can’t play pro hockey [in the UK] without a neck guard, you can’t go on the ice without one.” North America’s NHL, the pinnacle of the sport, still does not mandate the use of neck guards, although they are enforced in the lower American leagues.

***

Johnson was born and brought up in Minnesota in the US. He caught the ice hockey bug at school and went on to play with NHL team the Pittsburgh Penguins before moving to Europe.

Nottingham-born Kelsall got into hockey at an even younger age than his former teammate. “My parents would take me to skate at the national ice centre, they’d put a lot of toys on the ice and parents would take their tiny little kids, so I was on the ice from two years old and then from four years old I started trying to put the equipment on and skate around trying to play. My parents had season tickets to the Panthers so when I was old enough to go they took me along, and I was hooked. It’s a game that’s really exciting to watch, it’s fast paced, there’s skill and also the physicality of it which is different to most sports.” He became part of the team full-time in 2019, was named British Player of the Year for 2023-2024 and is a firm favourite among fans.

As the 2024-2025 season began, the first since the loss of Johnson, Kelsall and his teammates were determined to come back and fight for a victory. On 1st September they beat Lausitzer Füchse 7-2 to win the GM Memorial Trophy, following up with wins over the Cardiff Devils, Manchester Storm, Guildford Flames and Coventry Blaze.

One factor in the team’s recovery and its strong start to the new season, Kelsall said, is the fans. “We had a great support [from them] last year, we really value that,” he said. “They helped keep the club together during such a difficult time, it’s something that will never be forgotten.”

Kelsall also noted that attendance has been exceptional this season, with many games selling out as fans turn up to show their support. “Our attendance has been through the roof,” he said. “Last weekend we had just over 6,000 on Saturday and almost 6,000 again on Sunday so the attendance is up for sure across the season compared to last year. We didn’t have a lot of success last year but people still turn out to watch us play and we appreciate that.”

He noted a shift in the team’s mindset since last season. “Every game is really important [to us], it’s like a playoff run. Whereas last season the objective was just to be on the ice and competing but ultimately it was different circumstances, we had different objectives as a team.”

He was unequivocal about the Panthers’ aims for the rest of the season. “We want to win everything we’re playing for,” he told me.

***

Back on the rink at the Steelers game on 9th November 2024 and the Panthers weren’t holding back against their rivals. A backhand pass from Kelsall set up Ollie Betteridge to fire top shelf across Matt Greenfield for an extraordinary equaliser 22 minutes into the game. The stadium erupted with cheers. But in the 36th minute, the Steelers went ahead again securing their second goal, leaving the Panthers trailing once more.

Nottingham Panthers fan Keira Edwards was watching the game with anxious concentration. “I got into the sport because my parents were into it,” she told me. “The first hockey match I went to was when I was seven days old.” She stopped attending for a few years, but when she moved to Nottingham for university, she decided to revisit her old love for the sport and attended a Panthers game. “I had forgotten how good it was, and I’ve been back ever since,”
she said.

The fateful game in which Johnson died took place soon afterwards. “It was probably only a few weeks after I started getting back into ice hockey,” she said. “It was a shock.” Edwards told me how the local community surrounded the team during their difficult time and in the memorial games. “It was difficult for everyone,” she said. She recalled the 2023-2024 season playoffs, held at the home of the Panthers on 21st April 2024, and featuring a showdown between the Steelers and the Belfast Giants. “Everyone came together, and it was just the nicest event,” she said. “There was a Panthers block for fans to sit in even though the team wasn’t involved in the match.”

The Panthers couldn’t have been more involved in the game we were watching, however, and the final third was intense as the teams battled it out for the win. The Steelers were on top form, but the Panthers were hitting back at every opportunity. Sam Herr fed a shot to Tim Doherty to score in the 48th minute but Steelers swiftly regained the lead with a finish by Sacha Guimond a minute later. The Panthers pushed for an equaliser to draw the game, but the Steelers secured their win with their final point thanks to an empty net goal to effectively end the competition in the 58th minute. Final score: Panthers 2, Steelers 4.

Kelsall was sanguine about the result, but determined to get back on a winning streak. The EIHL regular season runs until April 2025 and Kelsall believes the Panthers can make the playoffs, and maybe even take the title that has eluded them since 2013. The final for what would be a fairytale ending is scheduled to be held in the Motorpoint Arena on the 19th and 20th of April. “We play for a big club at the end of the day and we’re expected to win and we haven’t won for a good few years in terms of major trophies but it’s not through lack of trying,” said Kelsall, before pausing and acknowledging Johnson and the extra impetus that is driving them this year. “I think fans appreciate the things we have had to go through.”

More Stories